Top Categories

Run, hide, fight: School shooter drills can have traumatic consequences. But do they work?

Run, hide, fight: School shooter drills can have traumatic consequences. But do they work?


The 911 name got here in minutes earlier than midday: A 13-year-old at Slinger Center College yelled he had a gun, sending his tiny Wisconsin city right into a panic simply three days after the mass homicide at a Texas elementary faculty.

However lecturers and youngsters have been prepared – they’d practiced for this nightmare state of affairs each semester.

Employees turned out lights and locked doorways utilizing gadgets that latch into the ground. One trainer grabbed a baseball bat. Some youngsters snatched the golf balls stockpiled in every classroom, able to throw at an intruder. Mother and father and guardians flocked as instructed to the car parking zone of a neighborhood bowling alley.

Ultimately, it was a false alarm: The scholar by no means had a gun. The 75-minute lockdown ended after police detained the teen, and kids reunited with their terrified households.

Jason Ford embraces his eighth grade son after regulation enforcement responded to a name at Slinger Center College of a pupil having a gun. Could 27, 2022
Ebony Cox / Milwaukee Journal Sentinel

“The unhappy half is that our youngsters need to undergo this,” stated Jason Ford, whose 14-year-old son is a pupil at Slinger. “They need to be ready and even take into consideration the worst potential state of affairs.”

The incident left many questioning: would they’ve survived an actual assault?

It is a query worrying many People as faculty methods throughout the nation reevaluate their energetic shooter response coaching within the aftermath of the Uvalde massacre that killed 19 students and two teachers – a tragedy compounded by law enforcement’s decision to remain outside as a substitute of dashing to the rescue.

To raised perceive how college students and employees are taught to answer energetic shooter conditions nationwide, USA TODAY contacted each state and the 25 largest faculty districts. The findings present energetic shooter trainings fluctuate broadly, lack oversight and should do extra hurt than good:

  • At the very least 41 states require faculties to run some type of drill that might handle an energetic shooter scenario. However whereas a pupil in Missouri could by no means expertise an energetic shooter drill, college students in some Florida counties have them month-to-month.
  • Whereas some individuals advocate for conventional lockdown approaches, there is a rising motion – and business – instructing college students and employees to make extra impartial selections, like working from or preventing off a gunman.
  • Analysis reveals drills can have damaging psychological well being impacts for college students, lecturers and households. However researchers say it’s laborious to review whether or not drills really assist save lives.
  • College students or former college students — who have been possible educated of their faculty’s procedures — have been the shooters in three quarters of the 191 energetic shooter incidents from 1970 by means of Uvalde, in response to knowledge from the K-12 School Shooting Database.

Trainings and drills “could make individuals really feel higher,” stated Michael Dorn, govt director of the nonprofit Safe Havens International, a faculty security middle. However many, in actuality, are “unreliable types of homeland safety theater.”

THE LATEST: Police officers arrived with rifles, ballistic shield 19 minutes after shooter entered Uvalde school, documents show

Lock down, run, cover or battle? Coaching will depend on the place you go to highschool.

Amber Aguilar stated her two young children are educated to lock down within the occasion of an energetic shooter at their elementary faculty in Austin, Texas. However after Uvalde, she questions if youngsters needs to be taught extra about what to do if an intruder enters the room.

“The survival tales of those younger kids that have been within the classroom is one thing that none of us would have hoped or thought that we needed to train our kids,” Aguilar stated. “I feel all faculties ought to in all probability reassess their drills based mostly on that.”

Lockdown drills grew to become the “business normal” for getting ready for an energetic shooter within the wake of the mass taking pictures at Columbine Excessive College in 1999, stated Ken Trump, president of consulting agency National School Safety and Security Services.

“They simply have us keep within the classroom, flip all of the lights off, shut all of the blinds and have us be quiet within the nook,” stated Lucas Flory, 16, a pupil in Colorado.

Federal knowledge signifies most public school students at present have practiced a lockdown drill, which is used for any menace inside a faculty constructing.

Nearly all of states require no less than one drill yearly that could be used to organize for an energetic shooter scenario, and states use quite a lot of names to explain these drills. Many make principals file an announcement certifying drills have been carried out and require faculty boards to fulfill periodically to assessment necessities.

Energetic shooter drills, as some states and districts name them, are sometimes much less standardized than lockdowns, although many do embody a lockdown element. Some are unannounced. Some require guardian notification. Drills that contain simulations – with sounds of gunfire or employees appearing out roles – have grow to be probably the most controversial.

Choices about what sort of coaching to show usually fall to the district. College personnel and college students could obtain totally different trainings from totally different instructors, equivalent to non-public consultants or regulation enforcement.

Most faculties at present nonetheless concentrate on lockdowns, Trump stated. However within the final 5 to 10 years, there’s been a motion, largely pushed by present or former regulation enforcement officers, to show “options-based” fashions.

The U.S. Division of Training advisable faculties undertake such fashions after the 2012 Sandy Hook shooting, the place a gunman killed 20 kids and 6 adults. Presently, the division stated it offers varied coaching assets to varsities, together with on the “Run. Hide. Fight.” model.

Navigate 360, an emergency administration firm, teaches the more and more fashionable “ALICE” strategy, which stands for alert, lockdown, inform, counter and evacuate. The Wisconsin center faculty that skilled the scare final month makes use of the strategy.

Whereas the drills concentrate on lockdowns, college students are additionally informed to “prepared themselves,” District Superintendent Daren Sievers stated. “Don’t simply sit again and be a passive sitting duck.”

Firms like Navigate360, that cost faculties for trainings, are a part of what Trump calls a “cottage business of safety, {hardware} and product distributors.” Gun management advocacy group Everytown for Gun Safety estimates the varsity security enterprise — which incorporates the “energetic shooter drill business” — is worth about $2.7 billion.

Mother and father, and even directors who carry trainers onto campus, typically assume a “increased authority” has vetted the curriculum, however that is not often the case, stated Kristina Anderson Froling, who survived the 2007 Virginia Tech shooting and runs The Koshka Foundation for Safe Schools.

“There are some for-profit firms which have tried to market themselves closely and have been profitable in getting access to faculties,” she stated. 

Rox Lockard, 18, stated college students of their Kentucky highschool have been informed in ALICE coaching to run, arm themselves with pencils or use a chair to interrupt a window.  

“I choose the working away technique as a result of it appears to be just a little bit extra environment friendly,” Lockard stated. “Particularly with how rifles are greater now and so they can bust by means of doorways, so the purpose of hiding within the classroom has grow to be like – there is no purpose anymore.”

One other technique often called “Run. Hide. Fight.” has gained prominence in recent times and is promoted by the FBI. It was initially developed by the Houston mayor’s workplace in 2012 for adults within the office. The mannequin “empowers people who discover themselves in an energetic shooter incident to have a voice of their survival,” the FBI stated.

Annika Tekumulla was a junior when her highschool within the Port Huron, Michigan, launched the mannequin. She stated her trainer instructed college students to seize scissors if an intruder ever entered. “We have been anticipated to battle for our lives within the classroom,” stated Tekumulla, now 19.

Newark Catholic students run from their school to Wilson Middle School during an active shooter drill in Newark, Ohio.
Newark Catholic college students run from their faculty to Wilson Center College throughout an energetic shooter drill in Newark, Ohio.
Jessica Phelps/The Advocate

In Uvalde, schools use a broader framework often called Standard Response Protocol for an array of crises, in response to the district’s web site. Texas started recommending SRP after the 2018 high school shooting in Santa Fe, the place 10 individuals died.

The “all-hazards strategy” provides faculties a standard language and focuses on 5 instructions – maintain, safe, lockdown, evacuate and shelter, stated John-Michael Keyes, who helped develop the mannequin in 2009 after his daughter was fatally shot in class.

Faculties typically use SRP as a basis for constructing out security plans, he stated. Final 12 months, the inspiration added steering for adults to “put together to evade or defend” within the occasion of a lockdown, Keyes stated.

Susan Riseling, former police chief for the College of Wisconsin-Madison, famous one 11-year-old woman in Uvalde smeared her murdered friend’s blood on herself to play useless. “She was processing to cover in plain view, to decoy herself. And it labored, as wretchedly tragic as that’s,” Riseling stated.

Do drills really save lives?

Simply having thought of an intruder will help college students put together. However it is unclear if drills really save lives, stated Sarah Burd-Sharps, senior director of analysis at Everytown.

Locking doorways works, in response to Jaclyn Schildkraut, an affiliate professor of prison justice on the State College of New York Oswego, and Amanda Nickerson, director of the Alberti Center for Bullying Abuse Prevention on the College of Buffalo. They’re co-authors of an upcoming book on lockdown drills.

Annika Tekumulla, 19, who was taught in highschool to run, battle or cover
We have been anticipated to battle for our lives within the classroom.

“The perpetrators usually would not have time to defeat the door locks and as a substitute search people who’re out in open areas,” Schildkraut stated.

Previous to Uvalde, she stated, there have been solely three faculty shootings since Columbine the place somebody was fatally shot behind a locked door: in 2005 in Red Lake, Minnesota; in 2006 in Bailey, Colorado; and in 2018 in Parkland, Florida.

Within the Parkland taking pictures at Marjory Stoneman Douglas Excessive College, a former student fired through the windows and doorways of three locked lecture rooms, the place six of the 17 victims have been fatally shot, Schildkraut stated.

“Whereas there tends to be a concentrate on the rooms the place college students have been killed, there must be an accounting for the entire different rooms within the faculty constructing the place college students do lock down and are bodily unhurt,” she stated.

IS MORE POLICE THE ANSWER? Why research shows that won’t help

THEY SURVIVED SCHOOL SHOOTINGS: Now their own kids are in classrooms.

Some faculty taking pictures survivors credit score coaching with saving their lives, together with college students who survived the assault final fall at Oxford Excessive College in Michigan, the place 4 college students have been killed.

“It is a part of faculty protocol to barricade, so all of us knew, barricade, barricade down,” Abbey Hodder, 15, said at the time.

People get emotional while standing at a memorial at an entrance to Oxford High School on December 1, 2021, following an active shooter situation at Oxford High School that left four students dead and multiple others with injuries.
Folks get emotional whereas standing at a memorial at an entrance to Oxford Excessive College on December 1, 2021, following an energetic shooter scenario at Oxford Excessive College that left 4 college students useless and a number of others with accidents.
Ryan Garza, Detroit Free Press

Operating or preventing seems to have saved lives in previous shootings when locking down wasn’t potential, even when college students and employees didn’t obtain that coaching. 

A handful of Sandy Hook college students in one of many lecture rooms the place the shootings occurred escaped by running when the gunman stopped to reload, Schildkraut stated. The gunman entered that classroom earlier than the trainer may lock the door, she stated.

Within the 2019 taking pictures at STEM School in Highlands Ranch, Colorado, college students who fought again “doubtlessly” saved lives, she stated. When one of many two shooters pulled out a gun in school, one other pupil attacked him and was fatally shot. Two others disarmed the shooter. The college makes use of SRP, Schildkraut stated.

“This consequence is probably going extra because of the human tendency to resort to battle, flight or freeze,” Schildkraut stated.

Within the 191 energetic shooter incidents at Ok-12 faculties since 1970 by means of Uvalde, there have been no less than 27 incidents the place the shooter(s) was subdued by college students, employees or different civilians, in response to the Ok-12 College Taking pictures Database.

A number of researchers and consultants, nonetheless, stated they have been skeptical of approaches that train college students and employees to run, cover or battle.

Encouraging college students to run from a shooter as a substitute of locking down may create a “target-rich surroundings,” Trump stated. He famous some faculties say that they are utilizing one mannequin on paper however do one other in apply, which creates confusion and legal responsibility dangers. 

As a result of it is “practically unimaginable” to review the direct impacts of drills on security, most researchers as a substitute choose to look at compliance with emergency procedures, Burd-Sharps stated.

FILE - In this Jan. 22, 2013, file photo, a student helps block the classroom door with furniture during a mock lockdown drill at Moody High School in Corpus Christi, Texas.  The actions of students who died tackling gunmen at two separate U.S. campuses a week apart have been hailed as heroic. A majority of school districts have now embraced such an approach, with experts saying educators need to give staff and students as many options as possible in the worst-case scenario. (Rachel Denny Clow/Corpus Christi Caller-Times via AP, File)
In this May 6, 2016, file photo, books and supplies litter the floor as a class evacuated the area during an intruder drill Forest Dale Elementary School in Carmel, Ind. A study found nine in 10 public schools now do active-shooter drills. [AP Photo/Michael Conroy]
LEFT: A pupil helps block a door throughout a lockdown drill at Moody Excessive College in Corpus Christi, Texas, on Jan. 22, 2013. RIGHT: Books and provides litter the ground after a category evacuated throughout an intruder drill at Forest Dale Elementary College in Carmel, Indiana, on Could 6, 2016.
LEFT: A pupil helps block a door throughout a lockdown drill at Moody Excessive College in Corpus Christi, Texas, on Jan. 22, 2013. RIGHT: Books and provides litter the ground after a category evacuated throughout an intruder drill at Forest Dale Elementary College in Carmel, Indiana, on Could 6, 2016.
LEFT: A pupil helps block a door throughout a lockdown drill at Moody Excessive College in Corpus Christi, Texas, on Jan. 22, 2013. RIGHT: Books and provides litter the ground after a category evacuated throughout an intruder drill at Forest Dale Elementary College in Carmel, Indiana, on Could 6, 2016.
RACHEL DENNY CLOW/CORPUS CHRISTI CALLER TIMES; MICHAEL CONROY/AP

Dorn stated his nonprofit has examined quite a few response fashions at hundreds of colleges in 45 states faculties, together with assessments of SRP, ALICE and “Run. Disguise. Struggle.”

In assessments of employees educated in these fashions, most workers fail to implement life-saving actions and sometimes wrestle to “match the scenario they’re posed with to the format,” he stated. Many employees educated to battle again have tried to disarm somebody who’s armed in conditions “the place it will clearly be extra harmful to take action,” he stated.

Many forms of energetic shooter drills “depart individuals with a false sense of safety,” Dorn stated.

FOUR YEARS AFTER PARKLAND: Gunfire on school grounds reaches troubling peaks

FACT CHECK: What’s true and what’s false about the mass school shooting in Uvalde, Texas

‘Scary, lifelike drills can have detrimental results’

Whereas it is laborious to review if sure strategies protected college students from hazard, analysis has proven “scary, lifelike drills can have detrimental results,” stated Amanda Klinger, director of operations for the Educator’s School Safety Network.

Baby psychologists, dad and mom, lecturers and others have lengthy raised issues about how drills affect school communities, noting they’re related to despair, stress, nervousness and physiological well being issues.

Tekumulla, the previous Michigan pupil, stated most individuals do not perceive “how mentally draining it’s to undergo these drills realizing that it might be actual anytime.”

Peren Tiemann, 17, who lives in Oregon
Essentially the most scary expertise is when my faculty forgets to inform us that there is a drill.

After the scare at Slinger Center College final month, 30 college students “shaken by the depth of the lockdown” wanted counseling after they returned the week after the incident, and 5 went residence, stated Sievers, the superintendent.

Brennan Cruser, a former elementary faculty trainer within the Austin Impartial College District, stated her college students — ages 6, 7 and eight — have been anxious about lockdowns and would ask if the drills have been actual, generally saying, “we’re hiding in case somebody is available in with a gun.”

“We wish to concentrate on their training. We do not wish to need to cease and spend the time” on lockdown drills, Cruser stated, lamenting that educators are accountable for retaining kids alive.

Lockard, the previous Kentucky pupil, stated trainings have been traumatic for them as a younger child. Now, the latest graduate stated they’re “overexposed” and “blase” concerning the risks.

“It may occur to us at any time. There’s nothing we will do about it,” Lockard stated.

Sixth graders hunch in front of a wall and hold books over their heads during a lockdown drill.
Sixth graders hunch in entrance of a wall and maintain books over their heads throughout a lockdown drill.
The Information Herald

The psychological influence a drill has on a faculty neighborhood extremely will depend on how the drills are carried out, many stated.

“Essentially the most scary expertise is when my faculty forgets to inform us that there is a drill,” stated Peren Tiemann, 17, an Oregon pupil who volunteers with Everytown to advocate for trauma-informed coaching in faculties.

In 2019, an ALICE coaching at a center faculty in Ohio left several preteens bruised after a principal posing as a shooter sounded an air horn and a few college students, confused as to the right way to evacuate, fell to the bottom.

That very same 12 months, elementary faculty lecturers in northern Indiana reported being left bruised and bloodied after they have been shot with airsoft guns “execution style” throughout a drill. Eight lecturers sued the sheriff’s division that carried out the coaching.

SCHOOL SHOOTINGS: More kids are dying from gunfire outside of school

As extra individuals converse out concerning the harms of energetic shooter simulations, some states and districts are proscribing the apply. In March, Washington state banned drills that embody simulations or reenactments.

“There’s a spot for drills, however they will’t be this sort of simulation of an precise taking pictures,” stated Randi Weingarten, head of the American Federation of Teachers. “As a result of that’s actually, actually traumatizing.” 

Nhel Jallouk listens to the words of St. Lucie County Sheriff's Office deputy as he talks to the class of upcoming teachers about ways to defend themselves during an active shooter drill on Friday, Feb. 19, 2021, at the Treasure Coast Public Safety Training Complex at Indian River State College in Fort Pierce.
Nhel Jallouk listens to the phrases of St. Lucie County Sheriff’s Workplace deputy as he talks to the category of upcoming lecturers about methods to defend themselves throughout an energetic shooter drill on Friday, Feb. 19, 2021, on the Treasure Coast Public Security Coaching Complicated at Indian River State Faculty in Fort Pierce.
ERIC HASERT/TCPALM

Modifications after Uvalde: ‘How far will we go?’

Quite a few states and college districts are reviewing their necessities for energetic shooter response coaching within the wake of the Uvalde taking pictures, and several other have introduced funding for brand new measures.

In the meantime, federal lawmakers are considering legislation that might embody expanded background checks for 18- to 21-year-old consumers, grants for states to implement “purple flag” legal guidelines, and funding for college security assets and college and neighborhood psychological well being assets, amongst different proposals.

“Faculties needs to be specializing in methods to stop gunfire on faculty grounds earlier than it occurs,” Burd-Sharps stated.

In Wisconsin, Ford — the daddy of the eighth grader at Slinger — stated many youngsters are nonetheless struggling to sleep at night time, weeks since the scare. His son, who sat beside him as he spoke with USA TODAY, didn’t wish to speak about what he skilled that day.

Ford stated he did not know his son was taught to seize golf balls and throw them at an intruder. He does not like the concept of instructing youngsters to battle again. However he needs to ensure they study what they should keep alive.

“How far will we go,” Ford stated, “is all the time the query.”

Kyev Tatum, pastor from New Mount Rose Missionary Baptist in Fort Worth, visits the memorial at Robb Elementary School Wednesday, May 25, 2022, in Uvalde, Texas.
Kyev Tatum, pastor from New Mount Rose Missionary Baptist in Fort Price, visits the memorial at Robb Elementary College Wednesday, Could 25, 2022, in Uvalde, Texas.
BRIANA SANCHEZ/AMERICAN-STATESMAN

Extra from USA TODAY

Contributing: Romina Ruiz-Goiriena, Ashley Williams, Chris Kenning, Erin Mansfield, Trevor Hughes, Javier Zarracina and Doug Caruso, USA TODAY; Eve Sampson, Detroit Free Press; Molly Bohannon, (Fort Collins) Coloradan; Arika Herron, Indianapolis Star; Michael Trautmann and Olivia Krauth, Louisville Courier Journal; AnnMarie Hilton, The (Appleton) Submit-Crescent; Jonathan Horwitz, The (Palm Springs) Desert Solar; Isaiah Murtaugh, Ventura County Star.

Grace Hauck, Chris Quintana, Alia Wong reported for USA TODAY. Megan Menchaca for the Austin American-Statesman; Rory Linnane for the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel; and Jason Delgado, for USA TODAY Community – Florida. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.