Top Categories

Amber Heard, Johnny Depp and what we choose to believe

Amber Heard, Johnny Depp and what we choose to believe

Evaluation: Specialists in home violence and ethical reasoning say the trial exhibits who will get our empathy, who will get to talk, and what we nonetheless misunderstand about trauma and abuse.


  • The trial between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard exhibits how bias impacts ethical judgement.
  • Myths and stereotypes about home abuse additionally affect the general public’s reactions.
  • Specialists say Heard’s humiliation might be revisited, however injury to survivors will already be achieved.

Critics of the live-streamed defamation trial between actors Johnny Depp and Amber Heard say it is too weird to supply teachable moments. They are saying it is leisure, a sordid spectacle, a multitude of rabid followers and exploitative influencers. They argue there’s an excessive amount of power spent analyzing how this occasion matches into the tradition, displays it, refracts it. 

However many consultants in violence, ethical reasoning and home abuse say the case is a crucial cultural second. It exhibits who we consider, how we consider, and the lengths folks go to persuade themselves their beliefs are true.  

“The query about why we see various things on this case is deeply influenced by the ethical judgment that we make first. That judgment kicks in plenty of motivated processes. Once you already need to consider one thing, you want much less proof to maintain believing it and also you’re extra keen to just accept any proof that’s in favor of it with out pondering extra deeply about it,” mentioned David Pizarro, a professor within the Division of Psychology at Cornell College who research how biases have an effect on ethical judgment.  “Once you’re offered with data that goes opposite to what you consider, then you definitely truly begin pondering extra deeply about it to be able to counter argue.”

Depp is suing Heard for $50 million, claiming she defamed him in a 2018 Washington Post op-ed the place she referred to herself as “a public determine representing home abuse.” In keeping with Pizarro’s framework, if somebody makes the ethical judgment that Depp is probably going an instance of a person falsely accused, they may search for data that confirms that perception and consider it much less fastidiously than the data that disproves it, which they must work more durable to dismiss. The identical course of happens for the one that makes the ethical judgment Heard is probably going an abused girl denigrated by the tradition when she ought to be believed.

This may appear like Depp’s supporters utilizing audio of Heard admitting to slapping Depp as incontrovertible proof that she was the connection’s main aggressor, whereas downplaying audio the place he mentioned “Shut up, fats ass” to Heard after she informed him to place his “cigarettes out on another person.”  

Depp responds to his threats about Heard: ‘I am an insane person’

Specialists in home violence say poisonous, unhealthy relationships can embrace bi-directional violence with no main aggressor, and abusive relationships with a main aggressor can embrace victims who use violence as self-defense or as a approach to attempt to reassert management. No single audio clip can paint a whole image of the dynamics of a half-decade lengthy relationship.  

Everyone seems to be, broadly talking, watching the identical trial – albeit interacting with totally different snippets, tweets and takes – however coming to vastly totally different ethical conclusions about what the proof exhibits. (This isn’t a legal case deciding guilt or innocence, however a civil one deciding whether or not Heard was allowed to publish her op-ed.) Reactions to the case on-line and off – from TikTok movies to Depp’s guffawing trial viewers to the folks taunting Heard as she walks into courtroom – are coloured by biases, assumptions and private experiences.  

Blended in are a contingent of social media customers – from body language “analysts” to Bachelor alums – lots of whom could use the trial to gin up consideration for themselves, usually contributing to misinformation about trauma and abuse.

Nicole Bedera, a sociologist who research sexual victimization and perpetration, says many individuals who’ve skilled home and sexual violence are avoiding the trial, which can even be contributing to the bias we see. On social media, coverage of the case is overwhelming pro-Depp. Bedera says survivors who cannot watch the trial however who might want updates are doubtless participating with pro-Depp content material, which can additional contribute to biased views.

“It is unsurprising that the individuals who have been on the front-end actually excited to tweet about it, to make TikToks about it, to create a whole following about it are those who’re going to have the least quantity of non-public expertise with this sort of violence,” Bedera mentioned.

Private biases affect how folks consider perpetrators and victims

Intimate partner violence – which might be bodily, sexual, emotional or financial – is a public well being downside that impacts tens of millions of individuals in the US every year, in response to the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention. About 1 in 4 girls and practically 1 in 10 males have skilled some type of intimate associate violence.

A few of the most distinguished home violence organizations – which advocate on behalf of victims of any gender – say it’s not their coverage to take a place on particular circumstances, however they’ve criticized reporters and social media customers for sensationalizing trauma and perpetuating victim-blaming narratives. These narratives could make it more durable for victims to hunt assist and make it tougher for folks to supply help or maintain perpetrators accountable, together with mates, household, jurors, judges and regulation enforcement. 

Bedera mentioned analysis exhibits folks have a really particular concept of what a perpetrator of intimate associate violence seems like. A few of these assumptions are gendered, some are racist, some developed as a approach for folks to manage in societies the place interpersonal violence is pervasive. It is uncomfortable, Bedera says, for folks to assume somebody they care about or admire or didn’t initially assume was threatening may deceive them in that approach. 

Individuals even have particular concepts about what a sufferer seems like – meek, virtuous, non-retaliatory, feminine. Good. 

The general public made Amber Heard a villain: Experts say it’s a dangerous moment for domestic violence.

‘Probably the most intense violation of my life’: A beloved camp, a lost boy and the lifelong impact of child sexual trauma

“Everyone brings one thing from their very own experiences to problems with home violence,” mentioned Kiersten Stewart, director of public coverage and advocacy on the nonprofit Futures With out Violence. “We deliver our personal ideas and concepts, and our private experiences as effectively. And each time someone has private expertise with a difficulty, that usually might be very deeply felt.”

These private experiences can create empathy or disdain for both Depp or Heard. 

“It is a unhappy scenario, when it comes to how the general public is responding to it,” mentioned Sherry Hamby, founding editor of the American Psychological Affiliation journal Psychology of Violence. “There are such a lot of biases. And never simply the aware biases, but in addition these unconscious cognitive ones.”

Dynamics of abuse

Depp’s legal professionals didn’t put a home violence professional on the stand, although they did name Laurel Anderson, the couple’s former marriage counselor who testified that there was “mutual abuse” within the relationship. (Specialists in home violence say the time period “mutual abuse” is a misnomer since abuse is usually about one individual wanting energy and management over the opposite.)

Psychologist: Amber Heard suffered PTSD, sexual abuse in Johnny Depp relationship

Heard’s crew known as home violence professional Daybreak Hughes, a forensic and medical psychologist who has labored within the Household Violence Program of the Nova Southeastern Group Psychological Well being Heart and was the analysis coordinator for the Sexual Abuse Survivors Program at Nova Southeastern College. Hughes evaluated Heard for roughly 29 hours and diagnosed her with post-traumatic stress disorder caused by what she said was Depp’s intimate partner violence.

Whereas Hughes was criticized for talking in gendered phrases about abuse (she/her for sufferer and he/him for perpetrator, which she defined was based mostly on her conclusion that Heard was the sufferer within the relationship), she stays the one individual on the trial who has testified about what abusive behaviors appear like and the way victims can reply. Hughes disagreed with the findings of Shannon Curry, a psychologist employed by Depp’s facet who testified that Heard was “exaggerating” her signs and suffers from borderline personality disorder and histrionic personality disorder. Hughes mentioned Curry’s strategies used throughout her analysis have been flawed. 

Hughes’s testimony didn’t seem to offer any pendulum impact, at the very least on social media. On TikTok, the hashtag #JusticeForJohnnyDepp at the moment has practically 15 billion views and rising. The hashtag #JusticeForAmberHeard has 51 million. Specialists say as a result of many individuals don’t view Heard as a “good sufferer,” they refuse to consider she could also be a sufferer in any respect.

Social media: Before Amber Heard took the stand, Johnny Depp had already won

“The general public usually expects victims of home violence to be good folks. They need this pure, usually passive view of them,” Stewart mentioned. “However somebody might be indignant. Somebody can battle again, and so they’re nonetheless a sufferer of home violence.”

These most certified to view the case objectively are home violence consultants, lots of whom say the general public’s remedy of Heard particularly stems from deeply entrenched myths about home violence, together with that false experiences of home and sexual abuse are widespread (they are not) that victims would by no means battle again (they often do), {that a} sufferer would have left if it was that dangerous (leaving is harder than one might think), that narrative inconsistencies make a liar (memory distortion is a feature of trauma) and that every one abusers perpetrate in each relationship (they do not).

‘It’s not simply the survivors who’re listening, perpetrators are additionally listening’

The Depp and Heard case is extremely sensationalized. Depp’s followers are screaming his title outdoors courtroom and jokes in regards to the case are being made on “SNL.” In a since deleted TikTok, singer Lance Bass mockingly reenacted Heard’s testimony.

“A few of what we’ve seen to this point … can work to additional hurt. From the headlines, to the memes, to the hashtags, these messages are perpetuating stigma and sufferer blaming and – very doubtless  – working to additional isolate and silence survivors,” mentioned Deborah J. Vagins, president and CEO of the Nationwide Community to Finish Home Violence. “It’s not simply the survivors who’re listening, perpetrators are additionally listening.”

Whereas social media response to the case has been merciless and derisive, Stewart cautions towards making broad generalizations based mostly on that content material.

“I do not know if persons are watching the trial that intently and … the algorithms exist to feed you what you are desirous about,” she mentioned. “It is virtually a tautology. So while you measure what number of instances someone’s seen one thing, understand that they have been fed that too. I do assume it is vital that we not assume that what we’re seeing on social media is certainly true public opinion.”

How will we view the Johnny Depp, Amber Heard case in 10 years? 

Pizarro mentioned ethical judgments can evolve over time, and he expects individuals who really feel fervent in regards to the case now might imagine otherwise about it as soon as it concludes. 

“We have now at the very least some proof that these extremely emotional judgments do change over time,” he mentioned. “In 10 years, if it seems that there was extra to Amber Heard’s testimony than folks gave her credit score for, folks will selectively do not forget that they thought that the entire time. … They will say, ‘I at all times knew there was an opportunity.’ They only do not need to be flawed.”

It is potential folks may additionally re-examine the humiliation of Heard. Her expertise is paying homage to different circumstances the place girls have been publicly scorned and later re-evaluated, together with Lorena Bobbitt, Monica Lewinsky, Anita Hill and Britney Spears.   

Marilyn Manson: Sues Evan Rachel Wood for defamation amid sex abuse allegations

Specialists say the trial highlights structural issues – in media reporting, within the energy of social media platforms, in the best way gender inequality is addressed, in the best way the justice system could turn into weaponized, in the best way all of us turn into complicit in retraumatizing individuals who have skilled profound hurt. 

“It is all coming collectively without delay, and naturally sooner or later we will revisit it. However revisiting will not be sufficient,” Bedera mentioned. “It is why it is so vital to determine methods to get this proper the primary time.” 

You might also be desirous about:

In case you are a sufferer of home violence, The National Domestic Violence Hotline permits you to communicate confidentially with skilled advocates on-line or by the telephone, which they advocate for many who assume their on-line exercise is being monitored by their abuser (800-799-7233). They may help survivors develop a plan to attain security for themselves and their youngsters.

Secure Horizon’s hotline affords disaster counseling, security planning, and help discovering shelters 1(800) 621-HOPE (4673). It additionally has a chat feature the place you may attain out for assist from a pc or telephone confidentially. 

Survivors may also name the New York Metropolis Anti-Violence Undertaking’s 24/7 English/Spanish hotline at 212-714-1141 and get help. If calling isn’t secure however e mail is feasible, make a report at and depart secure contact data, and somebody will attain out.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.