Top Categories

Got an injury? Should you reach for an ice pack or heating pad?

Got an injury? Should you reach for an ice pack or heating pad?

In case you are injured, must you apply ice or warmth to deal with the ache? An ER physician explains.


There are a whopping 35 million visits to emergency departments throughout the nation yearly for accidents. A majority of those are musculoskeletal accidents managed with X-ray imaging, splinting and doable orthopedic surgical procedure consults. Most acute ache from secure fractures and sprains could be managed with customary treatment like acetaminophen, ibuprofen and narcotics.

The bigger debate amongst emergency physicians and orthopedic surgeons facilities is round which extra non-pharmacological therapy technique is healthier for ache discount and therapeutic – chilly or warmth remedy.

There’s restricted information evaluating the 2 modalities in head-to-head trials. Individually, both have demonstrated reduction in acute pain in small studies. I’ve discovered that the majority docs will suggest sufferers use one or the opposite primarily based on their very own anecdotal expertise. 

Know earlier than you go: The dos and don’ts of going to the ER

Do you undergo from decrease again ache? It may be time to think outside the medicine cabinet

What’s the science behind warmth and chilly software for ache administration? 

Software of chilly remedy like an ice pack alerts the mind to set off a posh physiological response. The muscular wall of blood vessels contracts in a course of often called vasoconstriction. This vasoconstriction reduces blood move to the affected space, which successfully limits irritation and tampers ache.

Chilly remedy choices embrace:

  • Ice packs
  • Ice baths
  • Coolant spray
  • Ice therapeutic massage

Warmth remedy, then again, relaxes blood vessel wall muscle tissues by way of vasodilation, which widens their diameter and will increase blood move. Warmth remedy enhances circulation and move of therapeutic vitamins to the injured space. Just like chilly remedy, it additionally has been proven to cut back ache. In actual fact, a systematic review of 32 randomized-control trials featuring over 1,000 study participants demonstrated that each chilly and warmth have been efficient in lowering ache.

Warmth remedy choices embrace each dry and moist warmth choices:

Do you know…? Epsom salt should be a staple in your home medicine cabinet

The reply could shock you: Can spending more time in the sauna save your life?

Common rule: 20 minutes on, 20 minutes off

As a rule of thumb, it’s best to apply chilly or warmth remedy for 20 minutes, then take a 20-minute break. 

On the whole, hot and cold remedy is a good choice for a lot of sufferers. Nonetheless, by no means apply chilly or sizzling on to an open wound. Sufferers with continual medical issues resembling diabetes, dermatitis, a number of sclerosis and vascular illness ought to train warning or seek the advice of their physician first.

The underside line: Each ice and warmth are an choice. I personally suggest utilizing a 20-minute chilly remedy classes for acute harm ache. Ice works very properly to each scale back ache and swelling. After 72 hours, change over to warmth to extend blood move, improve therapeutic and scale back stiffness within the affected space.

Michael Daignault, MD, is a board-certified ER physician in Los Angeles. He studied World Well being at Georgetown College and has a Medical Diploma from Ben-Gurion College. He accomplished his residency coaching in emergency medication at Lincoln Medical Middle within the South Bronx. He’s additionally a former United States Peace Corps Volunteer. Discover him on Instagram @dr.daignault

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.